Directed by Arthur Penn
Written by Arthur Penn and Venable Herndon, from the song by Arlo Guthrie.
Starring Arlo Guthrie, Pat Quinn, James Broderick, William Obanhein
In 1969, Arthur Penn was riding high, having had a critical and popular smash with Bonnie and Clyde. It became a counterculture phenomenon, and that may be why he chose for his next feature film the anti-establishment protest song, “Alice’s Restaurant.”
The song, if you don’t know it, is about Arlo Guthrie’s arrest for littering, which kept him out of the army during the Vietnam era. The original version is over 18 minutes long* and is a dryly humorous song with an antiwar message. It was a standard on college campuses in the 60s.
The movie follows Arlo Guthrie (Arlo Guthrie) as he meanders from from Montana (where his long hair and hippie looks don’t sit well) to his friends Alice (Pat Quinn) and Ray Brock (James Broderick) for Thanksgiving. Guthrie decides to do them a favor and take their garbage to the dump. When he finds out it’s closed, he dumps it with another pile of garbage. The next day, Officer Obie (William Obanhein) arrests him and charges him with littering.
The movie expands on the song by showing more about the relationship of Ray and Alice, and also Arlo with his girlfriends. It meanders along, buoyed by Arlo’s laid back and sly performance as himself.
But the find of the film is the actor playing the part of Office Obie. William Obanhein is uncannily like the real Officer Obie – because he is the real Officer Obie.** He had spent his life as a cop in Stockbridge and when he heard they were going to make the movie, insisted on playing himself, saying, "If anyone is going to make a fool out of me, it might as well be me!" After the movie came out, he was critically praised, but he ignored Hollywood and went back to Stockbridge.***
The movie is a mixture of moments than a plot-driven film, incidents rather than story. But it’s an entertaining artifact of the hippie years.
*About the same length as the gap in the Nixon Watergate tapes. Hmmmmn.
**The judge who sentenced Guthrie to a $50 fine also plays himself. Alice and Ray Brock appear as extras.
***I find that admirable.