(1946)
Directed by Henry Koster
Written by Myles Connolly
Starring Kathryn Grayson, June Allyson, Jimmy Durante, Lauritz Melchior, Peter Lawford
IMDB
Entry
I stumbled upon a list of movies that Martin Scorsese thinks everyone should see. It's an eclectic list, but the one that stood out for me -- because it seemed so far from what Scorsese was known for -- was Two Sisters from Boston. So I had to check it out.
The story is set in the early 1900s. The Chandler family, a group of snooty Boston Brahmins, is scandalized to hear their daughter Abagail (Kathryn Grayson) is working as a singer at a saloon on the Bowery in New York (and -- even worse -- showing her legs!). They go to see her. Abagail tells them that she is actually performing at the Metropolitan Opera. The next day. She gets help from her stage partner Spike (Jimmy Durante), who takes it upon himself to get her onto the stage, which he does by implying that she is the mistress of the opera manager. She sings, but incites the wrath of the company's tenor, Olaf Olstrom (Lauritz Melchior). Her sister Martha (June Allyson) discovers the truth, and goes to the opera manager, but meets with his son Lawrence (Peter Lawford), who believes in Jimmy's rumor and thinks it's a blackmail attempt.
The movie is inarguably fun. It plays with the stuffy Bostonian stereotype and the reaction to the rumor about Abagail. It's notable that they can imply that she's the opera manager's mistress, but it's never actually stated, so younger viewers of the time wouldn't catch it. The songs are also quite good and all of them are performed where they would naturally be singing.
Jimmy Durante, of course, plays Jimmy Durante. He has several amusing scenes where he convinces someone that he's a long lost friend so he can help Abagail. Kathryn Grayson was a leading star in MGM musicals of the 40s. June Allyson* was also busy with musicals of the era. The two women are both overlooked today.
Director Henry Koster has a long career in Hollywood, helming a lot of musicals. His best-known film these days is probably the classic Jimmy Stewart vehicle, Harvey.
_________________________________________________________________
*Cast as a replacement for Judy Garland